Paneling: is it officially over or just undergoing a revival?
A wave of wainscoting is crashing over home renovations, but is it a trend or a genuine return? Experts weigh in on whether this decorative detail has reached its peak, or if a fresh wave is on the horizon.
The wainscoting buzz: a momentary mania?
The question is on everyone’s lips: have we reached peak panelling? A recent report from House & Garden’s team highlighted a concerning trend – an overwhelming influx of newly-paneled walls across social media, often executed with varying degrees of success. While beautifully integrated, too frequently it feels forced, derivative, and ultimately, a bit…much.
Decoding the panel: context is key
So, how do you discern a panelling triumph from a disaster? The answer, according to interior design professionals, lies in understanding context. It’s not about a blanket application of this style; rather, it's about carefully considering the architectural history of the building and its inherent aesthetic. Max Rollitt, a specialist in sympathetic restoration, emphasizes the importance of honoring the building’s past. “You need to pay careful attention to which style is appropriate to the general architecture and age of the building,” he explains. “Pick a style or time period as your guide, and adhere to it.”
Resurrecting the past: a designer’s perspective
Fellow designer Christian Bense adds, “Just because a room may not have any, that doesn’t mean it shouldn’t. Pretty much every period property renovated in the early 2000s most likely had any panelling removed in lieu of whatever was clouding a designer’s senses in those years. So chances are a room is actually crying out for a little of that panelling back.” The key, they both agree, is consistency – a harmonious blend of styles and impeccable execution. A poorly-executed attempt at historical panelling can be jarring, undermining the overall design.
Room-by-room considerations
Not every space demands the same level of detail. Brandon Schubert advocates for a hierarchical approach, suggesting more intricate panelling in principal rooms while scaling back in secondary areas. “Don’t just whack on some ornate panelling in one guest loo and expect people to think the panelling is original,” he cautions. But, he stresses, repetition is crucial. “Repeat similar details throughout the house, so don’t just whack on some ornate panelling in one guest loo and expect people to think the panelling is original.”
Beyond the basics: contemporary applications
Interestingly, contemporary panelling can work brilliantly in older homes, but with a crucial caveat. “I love seeing contemporary panelling in historic rooms,” says Brandon. “But I do think there is one important rule: it’s okay to use more contemporary panelling in an historic room, but it’s much harder to pull off historic-feeling panelling in a contemporary room. I’d say don’t even try it because it will probably come out looking inauthentic and disappointing.”
Practical applications: kitchens and bathrooms
Beyond historical authenticity, panelling offers practical benefits, particularly in kitchens and bathrooms. Max Rollitt notes its effectiveness in unifying spaces and creating a more cohesive layout. “In our Hampshire townhouse project, we introduced panelling in a few places, primarily to unite a space or rationalise a layout where it might have been updated piecemeal over the years,” he explains. “In the main bathroom, it was added to create a shower area that felt more era-appropriate than a glass enclosure.”
The devil is in the details
Ultimately, successful panelling hinges on meticulous attention to detail. Brandon Schubert stresses that even seemingly simple panelling requires careful consideration of proportions, materials, and transitions. “Even if you’re going for a more contemporary look, think about proportions, materials, transitions between materials, etc.” he advises. “The devil is truly in the detail when it comes to panelling, and even simple panelling is difficult to get right.”
Final thoughts: a subtle accent
Remember, panelling shouldn’t dominate a room. It’s an accent, a background layer—a supporting character, not the star. Let it enhance, not overshadow, the overall design. A well-considered paneling choice elevates a space, while a poorly executed one can quickly detract from its beauty. The key is thoughtful restraint and a deep appreciation for the building’s original character.